I've watched facility managers make the same expensive mistake over and over: they choose door operators based on upfront price, then spend the next five years paying for it.
The real cost shows up later. Maintenance calls. Downtime. Compliance violations. Security gaps.
Here's what most people miss: door operator selection is a systems decision, not a product purchase.
Start With Requirements, Not Products
You need to define three things before you look at a single spec sheet:
Traffic volume per day. How many people are moving through this door? A bathroom entrance and a main lobby require completely different systems.
Access control integration requirements. Does this door need to talk to your security system? Timing matters here—the electric strike must release before the operator activates, or you'll burn out the motor.
Compliance mandates. Accessibility requirements are mandatory under Canadian building codes and provincial regulations. Public entrances must be designed to accommodate persons with disabilities, and in many cases this includes power-assisted or automatic doors where opening force limits or usage conditions require them
Get these wrong and you're either over-spending on features you don't need or under-spending on capabilities you can't operate without.
The Hidden Two-Trade Problem
Most facility managers don't realize they need two separate contractors to install a door operator.
An electrician runs power to the breaker. A locksmith installs the hardware.
This split-trade requirement adds $600-$1,000 in unexpected electrical work before the operator is even mounted. Budget for both trades upfront, or you'll discover this mid-project when timelines start slipping.
Manual vs. Low-Energy vs. Full Automatic Door Operators
These three operator types are not interchangeable. Each serves a distinct purpose, with different implications for accessibility, safety, and liability.
Manual Door Operators
Manual operators are non-powered devices, typically hydraulic closers, that control how a door closes after it is opened manually. They are best suited for low-traffic areas where opening force requirements can be met without assistance. While they are the most cost-effective option, they provide no automation and may not be appropriate where accessibility requirements cannot be satisfied through manual operation alone.
Low-Energy Door Operators
Low-energy operators are designed to assist individuals with limited mobility and require a “knowing act” to activate, such as a push button, card reader, or similar trigger. They operate at reduced speeds and forces to prioritize safety and allow the door to be used manually when the operator is not engaged.
Typical installed cost ranges from $2,000 to $5,000 per door, with an expected lifespan of 10 to 15 years when properly maintained. These systems are widely used to meet accessibility requirements in healthcare facilities, office buildings, and retail environments with moderate traffic. Recent designs integrate hydraulic assistance to reduce motor load during portions of the opening and closing cycle, improving reliability and component longevity.
Full Automatic Operators
Full automatic operators are designed for high-traffic environments and rely on motion or presence sensors to open and close doors continuously throughout the day. They use continuous-duty motors, advanced sensing technologies, and multiple safety features to manage frequent use and prevent contact hazards.
Installed costs typically range from $7,000 to $12,000 per door. These systems are commonly used in grocery stores, airports, hospitals, and other locations where doors may cycle hundreds or thousands of times daily.
The key distinction:
Manual vs. Low-Energy vs. Full Automatic Door Operators
These three operator types are not interchangeable. Each serves a distinct purpose, with different implications for accessibility, safety, and liability.
Manual Door Operators
Manual operators are non-powered devices, typically hydraulic closers, that control how a door closes after it is opened manually. They are best suited for low-traffic areas where opening force requirements can be met without assistance. While they are the most cost-effective option, they provide no automation and may not be appropriate where accessibility requirements cannot be satisfied through manual operation alone.
Low-Energy Door Operators
Low-energy operators are designed to assist individuals with limited mobility and require a “knowing act” to activate, such as a push button, card reader, or similar trigger. They operate at reduced speeds and forces to prioritize safety and allow the door to be used manually when the operator is not engaged.
Typical installed cost ranges from $2,000 to $5,000 per door, with an expected lifespan of 10 to 15 years when properly maintained. These systems are widely used to meet accessibility requirements in healthcare facilities, office buildings, and retail environments with moderate traffic. Recent designs integrate hydraulic assistance to reduce motor load during portions of the opening and closing cycle, improving reliability and component longevity.
Full Automatic Operators
Full automatic operators are designed for high-traffic environments and rely on motion or presence sensors to open and close doors continuously throughout the day. They use continuous-duty motors, advanced sensing technologies, and multiple safety features to manage frequent use and prevent contact hazards.
Installed costs typically range from $7,000 to $12,000 per door. These systems are commonly used in grocery stores, airports, hospitals, and other locations where doors may cycle hundreds or thousands of times daily.
The key distinction:
Low-energy operators are limited-speed / limited-force systems designed to operate safely at reduced power, whether activated by a push plate, access trigger, or approved sensor setup. Full automatic operators are sensor-driven, continuous-use systems engineered for high cycle counts, faster operation, and more complex sensing/safety requirements for high-traffic environments.
Installation Complexity You Can't Ignore
Door type and weight dictate operator selection.
Sliding doors require sliding door operators. Swing doors need operators sized for the door's weight. A heavy door—steel, glass, oversized—requires a more powerful system to open and close properly.
Overhead space matters. Do you have enough clearance above the door to mount a standard operator? If not, you need a low-profile model.
Installation and integration costs often exceed the hardware by 2-3x when legacy systems and custom workflows are involved. Get a professional assessment before you commit to a specific model.
Access Control Integration Timing
When door operators integrate with access control systems, precise timing is critical.
The electric strike must be activated before the operator activates. If the operator fires first, it pushes against the locked strike and burns out the motor.
Some newer operators build the control units directly into the hardware. This eliminates third-party integration costs and timing conflicts.
If you're working with existing access control systems, compatibility between the door operator and those systems becomes a major factor. Test the timing sequence before full deployment.
Total Cost of Ownership Over 5-10 Years
Maintenance costs quickly outpace upfront hardware prices.
While routine preventive maintenance costs are relatively predictable, long-term repair and service expenses often drive the total cost of ownership for automatic door operators. Lower-quality systems frequently experience higher failure rates, resulting in increased corrective maintenance that can exceed initial installation costs within a few years.
Service contracts range from $100 to $300 annually. High-traffic doors need more frequent inspections—at minimum, annual checkups. The more cycles a door runs, the more wear on components.
Full automatic electromechanical door operators typically have an expected service life of approximately 5 to 10 years due to higher cycle counts and continuous use. Low-energy operators, which operate at reduced speed and force and are generally subject to lower daily usage, often achieve a service life of 10 to 15 years when properly installed and maintained..
Track these KPIs to measure performance:
- Mean time between failures: How often does the operator require repair?
- Response time on service calls: How quickly can your vendor fix issues?
- Energy consumption: What's the monthly power cost per door?
Measurable KPIs separate smart purchases from expensive mistakes.
The Decision Checklist
Map your facility's entry points. Calculate daily cycles for each door. Audit current pain points—security gaps, compliance issues, maintenance frequency.
Then match operator capabilities to documented needs.
Don't start with product specs. Start with workflow requirements and usage patterns.
Consult a professional before you commit. There are too many moving pieces—door size, weight, fire code, egress requirements, ADA compliance—that most people won't catch on their own.
A professional assessment upfront saves you from expensive corrections later.
What This Means for Your Facility
The right door operator decision comes down to three things: documented requirements, total cost of ownership, and professional assessment.
Budget for both the electrician and the locksmith. Factor in maintenance costs over 5-10 years. Choose the operator type that matches your traffic patterns and compliance mandates.
The upfront price is only one line item. The real cost is what you pay over the life of the system.
At Always Affordable Locksmiths, we help businesses modernize their systems with the same rigor we apply to sales and marketing infrastructure. If you're making decisions that affect operations, compliance, and long-term costs, get the blueprint right from the start.
Need help auditing your facility systems or building a decision framework for infrastructure investments?
We deliver Blueprint → Build → Run for businesses across North America.
